In brief
In a pivotal decision, U.S. District Judge William Young found that the Trump administration's deportation policy targeting noncitizens who protested the Gaza war was unconstitutional, siding with university associations that deemed such actions ideological repression. The ruling highlights concerns regarding political speech and the First Amendment, as lawyers argued that the policy created a climate of fear within academic communities, reminiscent of historical repression.
BOSTON (AP) — A federal judge ruled Tuesday that the Trump administration’s efforts to deport noncitizens for protesting the war in Gaza was unconstitutional.
U.S. District Judge William Young in Boston agreed with several university associations that the policy they described as ideological deportation violates the First Amendment. The ruling came after a trial.
An email to the Homeland Security department for comment was not immediately returned.
During the trial, lawyers for the associations presented witnesses who testified that the Trump administration had launched a coordinated effort to target students and scholars who had criticized Israel or showed sympathy for Palestinians.
“Not since the McCarthy era have immigrants been the target of such intense repression for lawful political speech,” Ramya Krishnan, senior staff attorney at the Knight First Amendment Institute, told the court. “The policy creates a cloud of fear over university communities, and it is at war with the First Amendment.”
Lawyers for the Trump administration contended no policy existed to revoke visas on the basis of protected speech. Victoria Santora stated, “There is no policy to revoke visas on the basis of protected speech.”
John Armstrong, of the Bureau of Consular Affairs, acknowledged during testimony that visa revocations had occurred for several activists amid this controversy, illustrating a complex interplay between immigration laws and political discourse.

