In brief
The Pentagon's plan to dispatch military lawyers as temporary immigration judges has drawn significant concerns from Democratic senators who argue it violates legal restrictions preventing military involvement in law enforcement. The plan aims to address a growing backlog within immigration courts, yet critics warn it could detrimentally impact military justice and readiness. The senators are seeking clarification on this controversial initiative.
WASHINGTON (AP) — A group of Democratic senators has expressed profound concern regarding a recent Pentagon initiative that plans to deploy military lawyers to serve as temporary immigration judges. This move, they argue, could violate existing bans on the use of military personnel for law enforcement activities and disrupt the military justice system.
The senators' disquiet comes in response to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's authorization of sending up to 600 military lawyers to assist the Justice Department amidst President Trump's intensified immigration enforcement efforts, which aim to mitigate a backlog of 3.5 million cases within immigration courts.
In a letter addressed to top military legal officials, the senators highlighted that, under the new directive, military officers would operate under the authority of the Attorney General, executing legal determinations that they deem to be traditional law enforcement actions—prohibited under the Posse Comitatus Act.
We remain extremely disturbed about the impacts on readiness of using military personnel to perform what are traditionally Department of Justice functions, the senators noted in their communication.
The letter seeks to clarify the sources of the military lawyers and the Pentagon's legal evaluations regarding the Posse Comitatus Act, which limits military involvement in civilian law enforcement unless in emergencies. Although a memo indicates that attorneys would not serve beyond six months, concerns linger over the ramifications of reallocating military personnel from judicial responsibilities.
This plan risks undermining efforts made by Congress to reform military justice procedures, including establishing the Offices of Special Trial Counsel (OSTCs) aimed at ensuring independent judicial processes for serious military crimes. The senators are worried that the diversion of military lawyers will negatively affect ongoing reforms and ultimately impact service personnel involved in military judicial processes.
As the Pentagon grapples with its approach to immigration enforcement, the senators emphasize that prioritizing immigration policies over the integrity and functionality of military justice is misguided.

