"The Awards Dilemma: Why 'Emilia Pérez' Struggles in Its Home Country"

'Emilia Pérez,' set to compete in 13 Academy Award categories, has been criticized in Mexico for its portrayal of the country and issues related to its production. While the film enjoys international success, it struggles to resonate with local audiences.

"Emilia Pérez," a controversial Mexican film about a transgender cartel leader reconciling with her past, arrives at the 2025 Academy Awards with a staggering 13 nominations—making it the most nominated non-English language film to date. It garnered significant acclaim, including a Golden Globe for best comedy or musical. However, its reception in Mexico has been far from favorable.

Critics argue that the film misrepresents the reality of cartel violence prevalent in Mexico, downplaying its brutality. The lack of Mexican representation among the cast and crew has also raised eyebrows. Comments made by French director Jacques Audiard and lead actress Karla Sofía Gascón regarding language and race have further exacerbated tensions.

"Emilia Pérez" was not released in Mexican theaters until January 23, five months after its premiere in France and two months following its U.S. release. Unsurprisingly, Mexican audiences have largely refrained from supporting the film, leaving many theaters nearly empty and some spectators even seeking refunds.

While a satirical short film that parodies "Emilia Pérez" has gained popularity online, the main film has faced ridicule on social media, with numerous memes taking aim at its French influence. Francisco Peredo Castro, a film expert from the National Autonomous University of Mexico, rather bluntly stated, “It has become a real disaster,” reflecting the sentiment of many who feel the film does not hold up to the complexities of Mexican life and culture.